Hercules Candies homemade peanut butter cups are very labor intensive to make, but they are out of this world. When we say homemade, we mean it! First we make the shell of the peanut butter cup, then we fill it with straight peanut butter (without adding any funny stuff), then we top it with more chocolate. You haven't had a peanut butter cup until you've had one of ours! The homemade peanut butter cups are available in 3 varieties and are wrapped in colorful foils. Check out how we make them on our .